Feminism Friday - the personal IS political
January 5, 2007 by thinking girl
When I began studying feminist thought, I knew it would change my life. I had always been something of a feminist, believed in women’s equality. But I had no idea how embedded gender roles really were, how everything around us reinforces gender. Through feminist thought I discovered a huge body of work about race, sexuality, (dis)ability, poverty and class, trans issues. Again, I had always believed in equality for everyone regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation, class, level of ability - but I had no idea how deeply these identities are embedded within society. All of this led me to examine every relationship I had with another person, and adjust my methods of interacting and engaging with other people in friendships, in my family, in sexual relationships, in workplace relationships, in my interactions with strangers I don’t even know. It led me to examine the implications of my work, my workplace dynamics, how I earn my living. It completely changed the focus of my degree, and my future plans. It led me to question the music I listen to, the movies and TV shows I watch, and challenged me to give up music and movies and TV shows that I loved but were not coherent with the goal of gender equality. It led me to challenge my own identity politics, my privileges as a white heterosexual middle-class able-bodied woman, and what it means to even identify myself by these names. It led me to question the very body I live, the foundations of my embodiment, my personal biology and how my body functions. It led me to examine my political beliefs, the people I voted for. It led me to have a greater respect for the environment. Feminist thought, and the thought I have been exposed to through feminism, has changed my life. I understand full well the meaning of the personal is political. my question is, how can it not be?
I am not a patient person. Never have been. Oh, I have patience for certain things. I am quite good with details, and I can perform tasks that others find ‘tedious’ or ‘nitpicky’ with a high degree of accuracy. But patience is not exactly one of my strong points.
Lately, especially, I have been feeling very impatient. I am impatient for the completion of my degree, and I am impatient to find out where I will be going to school next year, where I will be living. But this isn’t even really the issue for me, why I am short on patience, what situations cause me to lose patience.
I look around my world, my society, and I see much to be desired. I see oppression everywhere I look. I see misogyny. I see racism. I see heterosexism. I see the poor starving, dying of treatable preventable illnesses. I see gay marriage being called down in parliament by my country’s leader and put to a vote whether to keep allowing gays and lesbians to marry. I see funding cuts to vitally important programs like the Status of Women Council. I see kids being born and then neglected, turning into bullies and killing themselves and their classmates. I see rape. I see torture. I see murder, even state-sanctioned murder. I see disease. I see hatred between religious groups. I see wars built on lies and continued on egos. I see cities and towns and villages being wiped out by natural disasters. I see capitalist exploitation. I see war profiteering. I see victim-blaming, everywhere.
and I don’t know what to do. I just don’t know what to do. All I know is, this has got to stop, and fast.
And so I talk about it. I write about it, and I talk about it. I visit other blogs and join in other discussions. I write academic papers about it. I talk about it with my friends and with my family. And I get encouragement sometimes. And sometimes I get D grades from sexist profs. And sometimes my own parents tell me they don’t understand why I am doing what I do, and that I should really think about doing something vastly different with my life because I will never be able to change a thing. And sometimes I get letters and comments from misogynistic assholes who accuse me of hating men, of being a lesbian (which is just so ridiculous, as if I would consider that to be an insult in any way - but the point is that’s how it is meant), of denying women their autonomy, of trying to take down men, of ignoring harms that men experience, of being a godless whore who is on the straight path to hell, of being a frigid bitch who needs a good deepdicking. I get letters and comments from men who want to prove to me how women ask to be raped, how men aren’t at fault because it’s just a natural biological sexual urge for men to rape women, or how violence against women isn’t really that big an issue. I get spammed with more porn links than I can shake a stick at because I talk about sex and sexuality and how pornography is harmful to women and female genital cutting and vaginas and breasts and clitorises and vulvas - many of whom will try any trick in the book to get you to click on their link so their site will pop up on your screen full of shaved crotches and cum shots and women getting fucked in every orifice they have simultaneously. I get unbelievable amounts of hits on this site from people searching for videos of female genital cutting, pictures of children’s genitals, photos of women undergoing pap smears, pictures of infibulated vaginas, and all manner of pornography demeaning and harming women from incest rape to women being fucked to death by a machine. The spam and the searches I receive on this site proove exactly what kind of sick world we live in where women are worthless and small. And each day when I check my stats and respond to my comments and delete my spam, I am alienated by the pervasiveness of this hatred that I can’t escape even as I sit in my own home and facilitate my own little space on the web.
And if I get upset by any of this, I am accused of being overly emotional. If I stick by my arguments I am accused of being inflexible and irrational and having too much pride to admit when I’m wrong. I’m accused of not being very nice, of not caring enough about men and their delicate feelings on the subject of how deeply patriarchy hurts them, too. Posts devoted to supporting and encouraging survivors of sexual violence get infiltrated by men who insist that women are somehow magically raping themselves - are responsible for their own victimhood. And if I lose my patience, or my temper, with insipid fallacious arguments along the misogynistic lines that ‘men are just better than women and it’s a matter of biology so stop trying to fight a losing battle’, then it only encourages them because they think they have found a chink in my armour, they think I’m too emotional and that emotion negates reason so any showing of emotion means I am weak and wrong and they can disregard what I have said and therefore they have won because they were able to remain calm and ‘rational’ - no matter how illogical or irrational their point. I’m sick and tired of repeating the same old stuff, over and over again, to rotating audiences who are unable or unwilling to get it. My patience is wearing thin.
so I don’t know what to do. can’t win. can’t give up the fight.
rock. hard place. me.
it is frustrating. it is infuriating. it is depressing. it is oppressive. It is exhausting. It is isolating. it is heavy and dark and cold.
I am so grateful to my readers who are supportive, who encourage me, who consider what I have written, who share my mindset and my goals, who inspire me, who engage with me, who challenge me, who teach me. I may be losing my patience lately, but I am not losing my hope, thanks to you. so, thank you.
the rest of you can kiss my ass.
I do not know if it is a losing battle. I would like to say it is not. I am not always so sure. I do know this. Win or lose, I would rather go out swinging.
And whenever I get real tired –
I go eat some ice cream.
It is amazing, when the world is going to hell around my ears, how much better just a little vanilla ice cream can make me feel.
You are not alone. You are not unheard. You do make a difference. Have some ice cream. Then hit ‘em one more time with everything you have got.
[dear lord, please do not let thinking girl be lactose intolerant, thanks, me]
Oh, Thinking Girl, I love you. I really do. You sing my heart, and my pain, and the heart and pain of so many women and so many victims of violence. I have tears in my eyes and on my face, and if I could hold you this moment I would.
Don’t ever stop. We are in a war, and you are a fearless soldier, like our mothers and grandmothers before us. Nancy Pelosi stated as she received the gavel as the first woman Speaker of the House in American history that “we, as women, have waited over 200 years for this moment.” We are moving forward. Slowly, frustratingly, forward.
I, too, am devoting my life to try to bring balance between the genders, through spiritual means. Is is difficult to talk of here. Most don’t understand what I am or what I do–it is foreign. I am a Thelemic Priestess, and my spirit is here to fight for freedom and equality, just like your spirit is.
So, I hope you find some solace in that knowledge. That though we may be thousands of miles apart, we stand side by side, hand in hand. You are heroic, and nothing that is worthwhile comes easily, or without much pain. I would welcome discussing this more with you in private if you wish to email me. If not, know that I am on your side, as are many.
nothing to do with the post i im reading &commenting for the first time here…
your opinions are quite interesting ..
abt philosophy every man is a philosopher it is just that they dont realise..
thinking makes you a person a complete one it requires nothing as everything on earth can think(when it wants to)-it needs realisation-that completes it.
i cant find any posts on philosophy though so ill wait till wait till you write about it.
if u have time drop by my blog it may interest you..
ahh.
fantastic entry.
i am the crappest speller on the face of the planet, but i’ve worked lots as an editor and on first read, i loved mostly the pace of that entry. so fantastically written. it’s mode pumped up its content.
nice.
and … just keep going.
the world needs thinkers like you in the law.
i’m pretty sure you know how to find your patients.
you have hope: that might be all you need.
you are so awesome. and yeah, that “emotional” vs. “rational” crap is truly some of the crappiest rhetoric we’ve got as a society. my favorite take on this subject comes from gloria anzaldua, here’s something from her “interviews/entrevistas” (introduction by analouise keating):
[i quoted some further analysis from that book over here]
oh, and i wholeheartedly second what max said, except ice cream doesn’t have to be made with animal milk, and anyway chocolate might do the job even better!
(or any comfort-thing, like having that support and encouragement you mention.)
thinking girl, you just have to keep going. strong minded people with opinions that matter are like flickering candles, keep that light burning!
Hey Thinking Girl,
Theres a lot wrong with the world today, and hopefully some day we’ll all be equals.
I believe things are getting better for women, though being a man maybe i’m missing something.
Anyway, your post was interesting.
I love everything you write here becauseit is all so well written and explained. The things that you write about make me think and want to read more about these issues. I’m not excusing any of those jerks that come in and derail threads and make asses out of themselves, but it is easier to adopt a more aggressive version of your personality online because you’re “anonymous”. I’ll keep on coming and reading as long as you’re here.
There is also a lot of postiveness (if that’s even a word) out there. I used to work in a middle school with some grade 7 boys. I saw a lot of respect for women. I saw kids from different religious backgrounds asking each other about their families and traditions. In my son’s grade nine social class they talk about current events and even discussed gay marriage.
So even though there are terrible things happening in the world, hopefully, with giving our children a good education, things will get better. Just do your best to be a role model … you will probably change a lot of people along your way.
Thanks everyone. you guys rock!
Max - thank you for your candid humour, it is so refreshing! I would rather go out swinging too, preferably after ice cream.
Lulu - thank you for your encouragement. It does warm my heart to have the knowledge that others share this with me, that we are joined together in moving forward toward equality and building a better world. Revolution comes slowly, but when enough people are committed, it does come. Thank you for your commitment, and your energy, and your spirit.
Vishesh - thank you for your interest in my writing. For me, everything is about philosophy.
Daniela - thank you for your kind words. I think sometimes our best writing is kind of frenzied, written in a blurt, from a deep place of pain or confusion or passion. I think I wrote this in about 15 minutes, just flew out of my fingers.
Don’t worry, I’ll keep on going. I have no choice, really. No choice at all but to continue to rage against the patriarchal machine that drives our society.
thanks for writing about your mother. sometimes sharing the pain helps others as much as ourselves. your sharing helps me.
Ruxandra - thanks for everything, my ally, my friend. The emotion, though it sometimes overwhelms me, also drives me, compels me, pushes and move me. Emotion makes me saner, not crazy or irrational. It forces me to DO something about the things that drive me slightly crazy, in order that I may feel more at ease in spirit.
It’s true, there is so much more talk of emotion and spirit in the writing of women of colour. I think white society really does its best to suppress emotional expression in so many ways, and pathologizes what might really be quite normal expressions of emotion - particularly in women - as hysteria (even the word ‘hysteria’ comes from the root [Gr?] word for ‘uterus’).
by the way, those pictures of Paris are gorgeous, and your christmas menu sounds absolutely amazing. you’re inspiring me to move toward veganism….
Aulelia - thanks for the support! I will, I’ll keep on keeping on.
Derek - thank you for coming into the discussion - supportive male voices are always welcome!
Gina - thank you for being here with us and joining in these discussions. it’s great having your perspective, and your support.
Laverne - thanks for pointing out some of the positive changes that are happening - it’s important to keep these things in mind. Perhaps this movement for equality will pick up some speed, like the way technology really seemed to explode this past century. We just need to keep sticking together, keep the solidarity, and keep building this thing brick by brick, even if it gets knocked down from time to time. The work might never be over for us, but maybe we can build something that others can take over and complete one day.
Thanks to everyone who is reading, even if you’re not commenting. I believe when more of us align our emotions and our desires onto the same common goal, the universe listens.
Your words say a lot of different things to me - a much older (55) - man, whose privilige is “higher”, but who likely will have less influence on change and our world(s) around us for various reasons.
Where people, particularly, but not exclusively men, say and do horrible things to you try to recognize that they are generally coming from a place of weakness and fear, often seeing you as a threat, often giving you far more power than you may give yourself.
Feeling your hurt and pain is important and necessary. Minimizing it isn’t helpful for your physical and mental health. Taking in criticism from those you care about often is hard, but absent cutting yourself off, which usually isn’t helpful, it’s hard to avoid it, particularly when you share who you are with such people.
Finding and sustaining in person - support systems are very important. Some of these People may not love you as your whole self, but may support important parts of you. Nurturing yourself is also very important. Loving and caring for yourself is critically important and often may seem hard.
It is hard to take on tough causes - and being a feminist activist is never easy! I hope that you know that you can ask many of us for support at any time - someone to vent at, to listen to or whatever is helpful.
Your life may never be easy. Hopefully you do and will find joy and happiness as you move forward. You speak very positively of so many things in your blog - of music, tv, movies, books and of course of people in your life.
You are yourself - and have no other basic way of living as yourself. You are a loving, caring, intelligent, strong person. You do good things.
You are hard on yourself when you in a sense seek “proof of your effect” on the world. Much of how you affect others isn’t visible to you.
I hope that you will find some sort of mantra or song or poem or vision - or whatever - that helps you say to yourself - “I am a good loving, caring Woman” - or whatever such a message may be rather than: “I’m good because ….” - your essence - your being is good - your goodness is Not based upon the Successes of Your Actions or even your Actions of your life. Your inner core has in Incredible Beauty within it - which simply Is!
Good Luck and Thanks for being a Friend and Ally!
I’d just like to thank you for giving me the opportunity to read such a fantastic blog. Not only your ideas and views tremendously helped writing my essays and reports for school, your philosophy radically challenged, and changed my conceptions and understandings of the society. You are one of the main influences that made me decide majoring in philosophy and Gender Studies at university. I decided to make Violence Against Women the focus of the human rights group I’m running at my school (started letter-writing campaigns). I tell every one of activists I know and interested friends about your blog that they should visit and read it every day. I can’t go to bed without checking what Thinking Girl wrote today.
I love your blog exactly because you show your emotions. And I love your blog even more because you are brilliant at describing your emotions. I can clearly see that you are very nice and caring to people who have different opinions and backgrounds, and I can imagine the depth of your feeling, belief, passion and compassion even from the other side of the Earth, thousands of miles away.
Thank you very much again for everything you do.
thank you Geo. Thank you. You’re right, sometimes we do look for outside effects to be our proof of success, of value, of worth. Thanks for reminding me that it’s not about that. It’s about who we are, and the measure of success is about people and how we can help them, make them feel wonderful, inspire them, encourage them. And sometimes we will never know what we have done for others. (Like Liberallatte - I might never have known unless I had written this post what effect my writing has had.)
And I think you’re also right - about fear. I think that there’s only really love and fear, and all other emotion comes out of them. Love and Fear.
Thank you for being MY friend and ally.
Liberallatte
wow, thank you so much for sharing this, the impact my writing has had for you. I’m very moved to hear that my writing here has had such an influence, to help you direct your studies and your activism. That alone makes me want to continue - that ripple effect of me sitting down and writing these posts, and people reading and gaining a new perspective that leads them to do something to help others, that is something I never even dreamed might happen. That is what it’s all about. Thank you for the work you are doing. Thank you for sharing. And thank you for seeing ME in and through my writing.
I kind of cannot go with the love and fear theory. For one thing, I do not think people are born with an inherent feeling of fear. And I think if you are going for base emotions, you have to go with base infant responses. I do not think fear is inherent to infants. I could be wrong though. Birds are born with star maps in their heads. It is called “instinct” and written off like it is not better than “learned behavior.” Me, I would really go for being born with star maps in my head. And maybe fear is instinct, it always there. I think human beings are so dependent on learned behavior, it is not. But like I said, I could be wrong.
Wow that so should have said “is.” How embarassing.
[...] latest post, Feminism Friday - The Personal is Political just rocks. Great reading. Highly [...]
well, thinking girl, I really love your blog. You know how much influence you’ve had on my thinking over the last year. I think your blog is important.!
this post is brilliant, thank you.
Hey TG, I think you’re brilliant. Keep on truckin’
You have every reason to be proud of what do, and you think, and make us think. You rock. And you are not alone between that rock and that hard place. And don’t forget that for each of use that comment on your blog, there are many more that are moved but stay quiet.
I think that one of the reason there is so much bigotery out there is that many actually do not notice it, do not see it for what it is. People tend to take for granted that society is the way it should be. But it’s people like you that can open their eyes.
Max -
I’m not sure… I think there’s basically “what feels good” and “what feels bad”, and we’re kind of taught to fear “what feels bad” so much that it’s all conflated for us. I’m not expressing myself very well here, but it’s something I’ve kind of held onto for a long while, the love/fear thing. meh. I dunno. oversimplification… maybe. but not if it’s true!
Thanks L>T, V (and welcome, thanks very much for the linkup), Craig, and Marc Andre.
your support means a lot. a real big lot!
I think that racism and sexism are in important ways a part of us in ways that we often do not recognize (besides the Super-Obvious) parts of both where they are easily visible.
As a White Man growing up in a Very White Middle-West U.S. town in the 1960’s I certainly was innocent in such areas, only recognizing much later how they influenced me. I remember being in a Civil Rights march circa 1961 - when I was 10 years old.
Seemingly we were anti-racist and would have been anti-sexist later on as the Women’s Movement grew.
We don’t learn of our racism (often) until we really live in a deep way among People of Color. Having a Black Partner has most recently made me aware of parts of my own racism.
Statistically White people see a neighborhood as being “integrated” when it has roughly 5% Black (or other minority) People. For Black People the similar threshold is around 25%.
As Men we live around Women all our lives, but we often don’t hear the voices of the Women. Understanding Women’s anger, fears and other feelings are important for our Growth.
It’s so easy - to think we know - and to live through our various types of Privilige, without being aware of how “the others” live (poor folks, People of Color, Lesbians/Bi/Gay Men/Transgendered, etc.) in a meaningful way.
Listening - really listening often is a good first step!
Thanks!
The opposite of impatience is complacency. IE: as in, I hope my enemies are complacent.
I hope your impatience increases with age, TG.
[...] Feminist thought, and the thought I have been exposed to through feminism, has changed my life. I understand full well the meaning of the personal is political. my question is, how can it not be? Read the full post at thinking girl [...]